Tuesday, January 27, 2009

LA Art Review: "For the Birds" at The Box



Here's the set up: in a small gallery in Los Angeles' Chinatown, two artists have installed an elaborate cluster of birdhouses and populated them with pigeons. Other than a camera and a television monitor projected upward toward the birds, the storefront gallery has been stripped of all furnishings. Its broad plate-glass windows have been marked so that the birds don't mistakenly fly into them. This is, perhaps, a "bird's space." Well, not entirely. For, our artists have also taken up residence in the gallery, albeit downstairs in a basement "situation room" filled with computers and editing equipment. There they will remain (dressed in fluffy, zippered, "bird-friendly" vests) for twenty one days - - one day, we are told, for each of the twenty one birds implicated in this business.



"What's the point?," we may be tempted to ask. "How is this art?" Or, less charitably, "What the *#%!?" As someone who likes him some performance art and is keenly interested in contemporary art more broadly, Old Ken wants to offer a few ideas on exactly how we might begin to make sense of work like this and, more to the point, what kinds of criteria we can use to evaluate it.



First off, let's go with the obvious. Despite the fact that these may be perfectly serviceable birdhouses, their craftsmanship is not relevant to the artistic enterprise at work here. (Parenthetically, I would add that an art exhibition on the history of well-crafted bird houses would be a delightful caprice, but that's for later!)



So, if this is not craft-driven art, how should we apprehend it? Clearly, this is art of a conceptual variety, where a situation is created in which an idea can be explored. But what of this precious idea? According to the press release from "For the Birds", we are told : "Attempting to orient themselves towards an 'other', to de-center themselves, the artists will bend their minds toward the birds instead of requesting the opposite."



Now, this is a fun concetto as it takes a venerable theme of Western art and turns it on its ear. According to tradition, St. Francis of Assisi was supposed to have preached to the birds. As we see in this panel from the 1330s now in the Getty, St. Francis kneels in visionary rapture to receive the stigmata while surrounded by small creatures of the air. So, as opposed to this indoctrination of avian life made familiar by Christian art, our artists in Chinatown are aiming to turn the tables. At least in part, their project is enriched by this reference to pre-modern art and the religious ends it served.

It would hardly be satisfying, though, to claim that the iconography of a thirteenth century Italian mendicant is much more than a passing reference in work like this. So, to get down to those points of reference that do give the work greater motivation, we could surely analyze the rhetoric that the artists use to discuss their project. Both choreographers themselves, so their press release tell us, the artists "consider choreography to be the dynamic juxtaposition of human an avian habitats, the fixed and changing organization of the space, daily and poetic activity (like the feeding of the birds), interaction with volunteers, and the transformation of thought over an extended period of time." Understanding statements like these would presumably lead us back to French philosophy of the 1970s - - to the works of Jacques Derrida, Michel de Certeau and others - - and need not detain us here.



For, there are at least two different strands of reference to post-war art that seem much more immediately influential to piece like this. First, by dint of geographical proximity is the performance art of Chris Burden (whose installation of Victorian streetlights is, incidentally, now on display in front of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art). What's crucial in Burden's work is the tradition of the artist literally inhabiting the gallery. In his 1975 performance "White Light/White Heat" at the the Ronald Feldman Gallery in New York, for example, Burden lived on an elevated platform in the gallery completely out of sight for the duration of the show. Of his new home as seen above, Burden claimed: "For twenty-two days, ... I lay on the platform. During the entire piece, I did not eat, talk, or come down. I did not see anyone, and no one saw me."

Here, we might be tempted to get nice by strongly comparing the birds' houses to the elevated "artist's nest" created by Burden, or to contrast the subterranean tele-visibility of our artists with the incommunicado Burden. More compelling, I think, is the powerful play with presence enabled by these works: the no-doubt creepy awareness that viewers must have had of Burden in his 1975 perch and the intense smell, sound and subtle heat of birds perceptible in this show. Both works, we could say, make us aware of properties of living bodies to which we otherwise have no access (and, likely, gladly so).



An even strong reference to twentieth century art made by "For the Birds," though, is to the work of Joseph Beuys. In works like "I love America and America Loves Me," the German Beuys lived in a gallery with a coyote for five days.



If, again, we wanted to think of the reversal of the pedagogical direction staked out with St Francis and the artists' statement above, we might also think of Beuys' famous 1965 performance "How to Explain Pictures to a Dead Hare," which we see reenacted by Marina Abramović above. In this work, as the title suggests, Beuys lectured to a dead rabbit on artworks in the gallery space. No doubt other references from the history of performance art might be dredged up; but, the point is that a piece like "For the Birds" can be plotted onto a grid of similar practices to which it seems to make reference and subtle manipulation.



Of course, not all of the references made by a work like this need be to the alexandrine realm of the artworld. Indeed, we might think of the immediate context in which the work is being staged - - Chinatown - - and what "living with birds" might mean to local residents. After all, China is home to nearly ten percent of worldwide fatalities from avian bird flu since 2003 and has just recently witnessed the first outbreak of the disease in nearly a year. Although installation artists are often notoriously indifferent to locals' attitudes toward their installations, such attention might be linked to the vague ecological agenda to which the artists make reference.



Here, we could tally up all the references the work suggests: to religious iconography, various strands of post-conceptual performance art, global environmental issues, and even a references to the history of art spaces as like laboratories, which I am sparing you. But, what does it all mean? An uncharitable reading might say something like this: art such as this loosely conjoins a number of references in a vague but evocative way. The pleasure to be gained from such work is nothing other than the stroking of the ego of the insider who is able to make sense of these arcane gestures.

Yet, a more positive version of this story might go something like this: ours is a culture of info-glut, one desirous of various kinds of synthetic processing of information overload. What makes contemporary works of art interesting is when they postulate relations (vague though they may be) between different domains of information and create mechanisms for understanding those domains systemically, analytically or otherwise. Whether or not "For the Birds" moves toward these latter objectives (and I am almost certain it does not), at least it provides food for thinking about what might make other works of contemporary art more successful.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, October 30, 2008

Praying, variously

I had been intending to write a little blog about the culture of "small cars" here in Southern California until yesterday, when I came upon this praying mantis on the lawn outside of the Huntington Library.

I had never seen one of these beasts before, and I had always thought they were green. A little web research (such as it is) informs me that female praying mantises are green, while those that are tan and stick-like—i.e. our friend here—are the gentlemen of the species. It was incredible to see this creature, which was probably about five inches long, move across the grass using its folded arms for support in negotiating the turf.

Following the "rustle of language" as old friend Roland used to call it, we might liken this mode of turf-negotiation to the aforementioned carts that seem to dominate these parts. Of course you will be familiar with the myths of Los Angeles and its car culture—how it subdivides not only the landscape but the population itself, alienating and scattering, leaving LA as "fifty two suburbs in search of a city."

Well, what has struck me is the specialization of these carts. Example? Well, I wasn't able to get a shot of this one from the correct direction, but on the passenger side was an inscription of dedication from some noble, charitable organization written in chaste white lettering. Directly to the left of said donor's inscription was the christened name of the cart—written both in quotation marks and shadowed italic script: "Pedro." As you may be able to guess from the photo, the gents who use and may well identify with "Pedro" are gardeners of the Latino persuasion. "Pedro" has been kitted out to accommodate their tools.

In other words, "Pedro" is visibly different in form and function from this "executive" model; let's call him "Anderson." Examples could be multiplied: I have seen various kinds of library carts, maintenance carts, construction worker carts, etc. In the present political climate, it's hard not to connect the dots between these named objectifications of professional/class identities and, say, the nearly-completed fifteen minutes of "Joe the Plumber."

All of this brings me back to the theme announced by our praying mantis and the wonderful, rapturous button I recently saw on an elevator. May it be so!

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

More Fun with Microscopes



After that last dour and rather text heavy blog, it seemed like it was time for something a bit more iconophilic.



So here is my latest little foray into microscopic imaging. I was experimenting with trying to take photographs through the microscope itself. What I did was I just put the object lens of the camera right into the microscope eye piece. I then used the zoom magification to adjust the image a little bit.



What's interesting to me about these photographs is that they show how objects under microscopic magnification quickly go out of focus. As the photos suggest, I couldn't get the eyes and the body of this insect to both be in focus at the same time. Thus, when I made the drawing, I was constantly scrolling the focus in and out to try to see both, to understand their interconnection.



I didn't use the photographic images as the working tools for the drawing, which they probably would have benefited. Next time!



I also wasn't so sure about the "crotch" of this fly. I kept envisioning this area of its body as covered with armor, complete with a codpiece and so on. I have thus left it relatively unresolved here.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, December 09, 2007

Idolatry Now



While on a trip to Philadelphia in 2005, Old Ken bought a copy of W.J.T. Mitchell's then newly-published "What do Pictures Want? The Lives and Loves of Images" (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005). I had taken a few classes with Mitchell back in the day, and was interested to catch up with him. But, the book sat on my shelf back here in London-town until last month when the story of the British primary school teacher Gillian Gibbons and her travails in Sudan with a teddy bear named Mohammad became headline news. Thus, what I thought I'd offer here is a little review of the book, and a suggestion of how it might help us to understand the Sudan teddy bear row.

What is immediately striking about reading Mitchell’s book is how “small” the envisioned world of images feels. That is to say, Mitchell relies on a small and well-worn core of theoretical moves: Marx on commodification, Freud on fetishism and the death drive, occasionally Lacan on the Real, and smatterings of others (Benjamin, Zizek, etc.) A second register is reserved for the British Romantic poets: Wordsworth, Coleridge, and, above all, Blake. Next, there are the theorists who only get cited as phrases—often book titles—that are repeated again and again throughout the essays: Nietzsche’s claim that philosophy should be done with a hammer, not to destroy the idols of the mind, but to make them ring; Bruno Latour’s insight that “we have never been modern”; Arjun Appadurai’s felicitous phrase about “the social life of things”; David Freedberg’s evocation of the “power of images”; and Hans Belting’s idea of “the image before the era of art.” Then, there are all the other ephemera of popular culture that get marshaled in a theoretical reserves: Jurassic Park, Sprite commercials, David Cronenberg’s Videodrome, political cartoons from the New York Times and Chicago Tribune, and (shockingly) two references to Garrison Keillor. But, at the core, Mitchell has two constant points of reference: the Bible (and specifically, the episodes surrounding the prohibition of graven images) and his own essays, which are copiously cited. As opposed to (say) James Elkins or Barbara Stafford where the reader frequently feels over-awed by the range of obscure, erudite citations, Mitchell’s book feels very “homely” and familiar in its range of references. All images, it would seem, can be routed back through Freud, Marx and Mitchell, leading back to Moses and the second commandment.

So, if it is not in the theoretical archive that we find any surprises, it is perhaps in the candor of Mitchell’s basic contention. The book’s repeated assertion is that we need to think of images as having various kinds of power, life or animation. Rather than denouncing this fact or trying to destroy its image-incarnations, Mitchell claims that the job of cultural analysis is to uncover what interests image-anxieties betray, in part by sorting out the kinds of “bad images” themselves (the book exposits at least four key categories: idol, fetish, totem, and fossil).

Mitchell gives greatest exposition to the contention that images have various kinds of animation—that they are like parasites and artists are like hosts—in an essay called "The Surplus Value of Images." So he claims, images, “form a social collective that has a parallel existence to the social life of their human hosts, and to the world of objects they represent.” (93) Although such an argument cuts across the orthodoxy of most art-historical scholarship—wherein images are understood (often unconsciously) as kinds of instruments made by humans for various aesthetic, social, rhetorical, political or other purposes—Mitchell is quick to point out that lots of different kinds of support can be found for the idea that images are always on the verge of taking on lives of their own. When confronted by Moses after making the golden calf in the Book of Exodus, for example, Aaron claims that he only put the Israelites’ golden jewelry into the fire and the calf “made itself.” The conceit that paintings found numerous advocates among Abstract Expressionist painters, and might be traced through art-historical concepts of kunstwollen, the notion that artistic styles ultimately respond to their own autonomous necessities, which are in certain ways independent of the instrumental values assigned to them by their supposed makers. And surely, the uncanny possibility that images can come to life is a motif of lots of fictional works: The Portrait of Dorian Gray, Frankenstein, and legends of Pygmalion or the golem being only the most familiar examples.

What the book tries to exposit, then, are the various kinds of ways in which Western culture has processed the problem of image-vitality. Mitchell sees the triad of idol, fetish and totem as central to this story and effectively condensing a history of Western thought. The idea of idolatry is very old in Western culture, Mitchell argues, going back to the religions of the Book; it “discloses the greatest surplus of overestimation (as an image of God, the ultimate value).” (97) Following the work of anthropologist William Pietz, Mitchell sees the fetish as a conception of the living image born in the networks of slave-trading in the early modern period, “associated with greed, acquisitiveness, perverse desire, materialism, and a magical attitude toward objects.” (97-8) Totemism, meanwhile, is a modern and more benign way of understanding the living image. Neither the false god of idolatry nor the perverse replacement of the fetish, the totem (as a category of analysis for the new, nineteenth century science of anthropology) denotes a conception of the image as a brother, protector or friend. Often an animal-form, the totem designates (in the words of Jacques Derrida) “l’animal que je suis”—both the animal that I am and the animal that I follow.

This talk of animals and animism leads us back to the uproar surrounding Gillian Gibbons, a teacher from Liverpool, who worked at Unity High School in Khartoum. The colonial context is important because, as with so many other places, Sudan has had first-hand colonial experience of British, who governed it from the arrival of Lord Kitchener in 1899 through devolution of power in 1956. From what the London Times reports, Unity High School is both product and reminder of this history; founded in 1902 by the Anglican Bishop, Llwellyn Gwynne, the office of the school’s director still displays “sepia photographs of the school’s colonial heyday.”

The specific incident causing the uproar seems to have unfolded in the following way: a seven-year old girl brought a toy bear into Gibbons’ class in September, at the beginning of the school year. Against Gibbons’ own suggestion, the class voted to name the bear “Muhammad.” As the Times (London) explains, the bear “was dressed in old clothes and was sent home each weekend with different pupils who were asked to keep a diary of its activities. Each entry was collected in a book with a picture of the bear on the cover, next to the message ‘My name is Muhammad.’" Although the exact circumstances of how this naming became known to authorities are slightly unclear, Gibbons was arrested on November 28, 2007 under section 125 of the Sudanese criminal code, charged with insulting faith and religion. Facing six months in jail and forty lashes, Gibbons was convicted, although eventually pardoned under substantial pressure from Muslim groups in the UK and British diplomacy. She has since flown back to the UK.



Now, I think a pretty compelling case could be made that, in the Anglo-American mind, the teddy bear is close to Mitchell’s idea of the totem. It is a friendly creature, a protector and benign denizen of the childhood (or “child-like,” as early anthropologists might have said) imagination. What is more, the perception in the Anglo-American press is that, in this case, a totem has been mistaken for an idol. That is, the Sudanese government’s condemnation of Gibbons has been described in the press as as much a product of the idolatrous implications of the bear as the more generalized insult to Islam implicit in it. In this view, Gibbons was at worst guilty of lacking in cultural sensitivity and, more likely, a victim of over-zealous religious fervor—if not a highly orchestrated spectacle designed to draw international attention away from the atrocities committed by the Sudanese government in Darfur. One can imagine an interpretation of this incident that would examine how the conceptualization of the teddy bear as totem, idol, fetish or so on enables various kinds of ideological work, reinforcing the West's idea of itself as an enlightened and tolerant community or of the Muslim world's conception of the West as lacking respect for its beliefs.

Topics like this would seem to be exactly the kinds of things for which Mitchell’s book is useful, insofar as it provides strategies for analyzing what people think others think about images that seem to take on various kinds of animism. At the same time, Old Ken cannot help but feel that this is also the book's biggest shortcoming or the return of the "small world" problem. Surely, most of the millions of images made and destroyed everyday come and go from the world without a peep of response or objection from their distracted viewers. The attempt of Mitchell's approach, by contrast, is to allow this distracted viewer to say something that sounds meaningful about those few, isolated cases in which images actually do arouse certain types of controversy. But, by framing these controversies in and through the Big Books and Big Issues of Western culture, almost any set-up will sound meaningful, whether or not it gets at the specifics of the individual case. In thinking about the Gibbons case, Old Ken kept wondering: what exactly did Gibbons' bear mean in Sudan? Who exactly was protesting against it and her? And how is the term “teddy bear” translated into Arabic? That is, does the name of an American president be significant? What are the larger available ideas about bears in Sudanese or, more broadly, Arabic-speaking cultures?

Mitchell's book is great for the blogosphere. It provides matrices for placing almost any given image controversy in relation to big theories and big stakes, whether or not the interpreter knows much of anything about the specifics of the given case; as you have seen here. But, whether it works as a model for studies of images in art and beyond ... well, Old Ken ain't so sure about that.

Labels: , , , ,

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Bloggus Omnibus: November



It's November-time in London-town. What does that mean? Cold rain, the sun setting at four o'clock in the afternoon. Consequently, when it's time for bloggin', things get a little wild, woolly and packed with double shots of the BEST!



How so? Dig on these apples. Eighteenth century statues of scholars on the facade of a Wren church in Hatton Gardens.



Take that!



Or check out these "architectural drawings" by Zaha Hadid.



Maybe not so useful when you're trying to frame up a garage or install a bathtub, but still pretty cool.



Okay, this one is a singularity, although indicative of things more broadly, sad to say. What is that pathetic thing, you ask? Well, that's what we here in Britain call a generous gesture toward handicapped accessibility.



Hey - - who is that in the back yard? No, no; not sitting in the chairs. I'm not talking about a ghost.



I'm talking about that sweet, sweet fox. Foxy!



And kabaam! Speaking of foxes, there goes Michael J. Fox, back to the future.

Labels: , ,